Northern Illinois University Press

One Nation under Law

America's Early National Struggles to Separate Church and State

Mark Douglas McGarvie

"The most innovative recent study of church-state relations in the early republic."—Journal of the Early Republic

"Unique and valuable... subtle and sophiticated scholarship. For those who specialize in church-state issues in America, this book is essential reading. "—Journal of Church and State

"One of the best scholarly works in years to argue effectively for the separation of church and state as part of the founders''original intent.' McGarvie proves himself in this book to be a superb historian of law and the history of ideas."—The American Journal of Legal History

The United States' commitment to separation of church and state has defined the nation, from the structure of the schools and the welfare system to the nature of American politics and society. Many citizens mistakenly point to the First Amendment, which guarantees the freedom of religious practice, as the origin of this separation. Indeed, the Bill of Rights represents a crucial step toward the division of religious institutions from the affairs of the government. Yet, from the days of the early republic, the separation of church and state came about slowly, amid contentious legal, intellectual, and religious debates.

In this timely study, Mark McGarvie documents America's transition from Christian communitarianism with its government-sponsored religious institutions to liberal republicanism with its insistence that church and government not interfere with one another. Surprisingly, for a half-century after the ratification of the Constitution, many early state governments continued to support religious organizations. Disestablishment nonetheless proceeded, gaining ever greater momentum as churches lost tax support and found that they could not enforce mandatory attendance laws. No longer public institutions with strong state backing, churches were reconstructed as private, voluntary associations. At the same time, the state took responsibility for poor relief, community record keeping, and a variety of other public services formerly left to the churches.

Providing a close-up view of disestablishment as both a legal and an ideological process, McGarvie focuses on the efforts of three key states—New York, South Carolina, and New Hampshire—to disentangle church and state during the early national period. These case studies are particularly enlightening because a single state's disestablishment crisis helped change the law for the entire nation when New Hampshire's attempt to convert Dartmouth College into a secular state institution ended in a suit that eventually reached the Supreme Court. One Nation under Law is an important contribution to an ongoing, distinctly American debate.

(2004) 269 pp., notes, biblio., index
ISBN: 978-0-87580-333-3
cloth $42.00

ISBN: 978-0-87580-606-8
paper $25.00

Mark Douglas McGarvie, J.D., Ph.D., is Assistant Professor of History and Law at the University of Richmond.

Table of Contents

1. Toleration versus Freedom
2. Revolutions in Churches and Society
3. "To Form a More Perfect Union"
4. God Is as Man Makes Him
5. Revolutionary-Era Disestablishment
6. Southern Republicanism and Constitutional-Era Disestablishment
7. The Dartmouth College Case

Shopping Cart Operations

ISBN: 978-0-87580-333-3
cloth $42.00
ISBN: 978-0-87580-606-8
paper $25.00